Se afișează postările cu eticheta Fitch Ratings. Afișați toate postările
Se afișează postările cu eticheta Fitch Ratings. Afișați toate postările

vineri, 6 martie 2009

Rating institutions, Eastern Europe, and Economic Crisis

A few days ago, the European national bank governors manifested their indignation concerning the alarmist reports of international rating institutions (e.g., Moody's, Fitch, Standard&Poor's). They accused these organizations of playing a dirty game by publishing pessimistic reports about the Eastern and Central European economies.

In this context, I tend to understand the silence some regional and international institutions keep about the way these rating companies work. But this is not an excuse, nor a motivation. The reality is quite simple: there is no transparency in the way Fitch, Standard&Poor's or any other company rates countries, cities, national economies or banking institutions. As some said, they work with indirect information, oversimplify and use ridiculous indicators. With this image in my head, I cannot take their reports as accurate or good-willing. On the contrary, I suspect they make the game of big financial institutions or countries that want or try to make a living out of the misery of countries like Romania, Poland or Czech Republic.

I do not believe in the economic crisis as many analysts from all over the world present it. I believe that the current economic tremours are the result of a general panik situation. The fear is bigger than the common sense, it overwrites the reason. So, almost all economic leaders, instead of boosting investments and become more creative in opening new markets for their products and services, apply the precautionary principles in every aspect of their economic activities. They prefer to cut down the costs with employees and use outsourcing in every way they can, while unaware of the exponential increase of the operational risk. They prefer to freeze training budgets and keep on stand-by all investments, while the people are ready to cope with the crisis and save their jobs. They prefer to gain as much money as possible in less time or not to decrease their financial expectations, while their previous investments did not focus on decreasing costs with energy, efficiency at operational level, with performance based incentives for CEOs and directors.

Returning to the subject at question, the biggest mistake Romanian government can do at this moment is to contract a loan from the International Monetary Fund. This institution is well known for its portfolio full of unsuccessful projects in any country they worked with. For example, Romania, until its refusal to work with IMF, introduced stupid public policies and destroyed the productive industry, becoming a huge consumer of foreign goods. This vision IMF imposed in Romania was translated from other previous projects, without relevant results.

Taking into account this and other information about the current economic (and political) crisis, and after the pessimistic reports of the World Bank and IMF, I cannot trust these two institutions. So, I would prefer to count only on what Romanian can produce as gross internal product and refuse the IMF, WB or EBRD help. I suspect them also of trying to translate the risk from western markets to the east of Europe. It is better for them to minimize the losses they have on the American market, for example, by trying to raise the exchange rate for Eastern European currencies, like it already happened in Hungary, Romania, Bulgaria, Poland, Czech Republic, Slovenia and Slovakia.

This is why I appreciated very much the outburst of Mr. Isarescu, the governor of the Romanian National Bank (BNR), when he realize there are some major banks that, with the complicity of mass-media, tried to manipulate the exchange rate for Euro/RON. The intervention of the BNR on the financial market made these banks to loose more money, but stopped the Euro/RON exchange rate at 4.2 and not at 4.5/4.75, or even 5.0, as the western mass-media and some bank treasurers said it would end up.

Now, we are facing another step in this scenario meant to transfer the economic risks in other parts of the world. And this step involves direct attacks coordinated by rating institutions. If the fall of American banks did not affect Europe so much, at least the ratings for Eastern and Central European countries will reach their target. And the effects are already starting to show up (e.g., the scary-crow with the Austrian banks).

Readings:
* my previous post - Fitch Ratings - a highly unethical rating agency
* "Cotidianul", March 4, 2009 - Guvernatorii Estului ataca agentiile de rating
* BBC - http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/business/7923685.stm

luni, 10 noiembrie 2008

Fitch Ratings - a highly unethical rating agency

Today, both Romanian and foreign financial media intensively discussed the new ratings issued by Fitch Ratings for EMEA on November 9, 2008. Many have said that the downgraded rate for Romania is just a speculative action orchestrated by big financial groups that tried to put down the Romanian financial market in the last weeks. But beyond all the comments, we can easily see that there is a huge interest in making all the 'emerging financial markets' feel the international crisis.

One question I have is how could they consider a two-notch downgrade for the sovereign rating when the credit crisis in Romania has been prevented by the Romanian National Bank? Moreover, how could they consider Transilvania Bank as the only Romanian bank that has proven a steady development? Is there a specific interest in making this bank available for future interbanking relations? If I remember correctly, Transilvania bank just suffered a powerful attack from foreign investors and speculators. (read here)

Here is the explanation offered by Fitch Ratings in its press release:
"Romania: the two-notch downgrade reflects Fitch's concerns about the macroeconomic policy framework in Romania and its ability to avoid a severe economic and financial crisis. With a widening current account deficit - expected to exceed 14% of GDP this year - fuelled by excessive credit growth, Fitch believes a much stronger policy adjustment, especially in fiscal policy, is needed to avoid a currency crisis. Given private sector foreign currency balance sheet mismatches, such an outcome could require substantial external financial support from the international community to prevent a sovereign credit crisis. The rating Outlook is Negative."
(Source: Fitch Ratings' website)

I have been following these ratings in the last two months and I can say openly that Fitch and other similar institutions are just one tool in the hands of big western banks and investment groups. At this moment, their interest (both of the western banks and investment groups) is to transfer all negative risks and unprofitable packages to the emerging financial markets because it is easier for them to leave the hot pie in other hands and eat the most of it when it will be ready-baked. From another perspective, they want to make more money even if their native or adoptive markets became unproductive (because of them and not because of somebody else). In other words, we are dealing with a huge greed.

It is very strange how suddenly the representative of the International Monetary Fund visited Romania before this new rating and soon after Hungary asked for financial help from European Union. Is it a way of damaging the image of a country with relative financial stability? We certainly did not invite them to discuss potential refunding of our economy. Our experience with them -- as in the case of all the other countries where they pushed in their strategy - was really bad, especially because their economical tools are inappropriate for Romanian context.

Taking into consideration all these and many other "incidental" events, I conclude that Fitch ratings is playing with the country/cities and banking ratings as their contributors dictate. It is a way of influencing the financial market, it is a way of making money on the backs of the poorer ones. From my own point of view, this is the most unethical behavior we could see these days. I think I am not saying anything wrong when I associate Fitch's current behavior with the Enron experience. They play with figures just like the managers from Enron played with financial reports and energy production.

--
Nov. 11, 2008
The article from the Financial Times is very interesting. Although the author tries to describe what happened, you can easily understand that our economic and financial situation is far better than those of Hungary or Bulgaria. The last has a 25 percent current account deficit, while the first received an important financial help from the European Central Bank.